La Superlativa

A search for the best italian restaurant nyc will not tell you which kitchen makes cacio e pepe worth ordering. Shape will. The dish is pecorino, black pepper and starchy pasta water, with nowhere for a cook to hide, and the variable most menus mention only in passing is the strand itself. A bucatini order and a pici order are not the same dinner. If cacio e pepe has let you down before, the geometry is the likeliest reason. Six Manhattan rooms currently serve it. Here is what each one uses.

Quick answer

Thick, hand-rolled strands: Via Carota on Grove Street, or L’Artusi on West 10th. The plain Roman spaghetti reading: Rubirosa in Nolita. Fresh tonnarelli in a quiet dining room: Novitá on East 22nd Street. Bucatini, which carries more sauce per bite than anything else on this page: Zero Otto Nove on West 21st. A bowl at three in the afternoon: Tarallucci e Vino near Union Square.

How these were selected

Every restaurant here lists a cacio e pepe on its own published menu, checked in early August 2026. Where a menu names the shape, I have used the menu’s word for it. Our selections prioritize rooms where the dish sits on the standing menu rather than turning up as a special, and they are spread across several neighborhoods rather than clustered on one block.

No scores. There is no single correct version either. Roman purists will tell you it has to be tonnarelli. Roman purists are also not the ones cooking on West 10th Street.

Where to order cacio e pepe in NYC

Via Carota, for the version you do not have to plan around

Via Carota lists it as tonnarelli, cacio pepe, at $27. Tonnarelli is the square-cut strand the dish is built on in Rome, thicker than spaghetti and rougher, which is what you want when the sauce is this thin. The room sits at 51 Grove Street in the West Village, and the restaurant’s own site says walk-ins are always welcome, which makes it the rare good pasta in this city you can decide on at 7pm. Hours run 11am to 11pm Monday through Thursday and 10am to 11pm Friday through Sunday.

Best suited to an unplanned dinner, or a late lunch that turns into something longer.

L’Artusi, for the chewiest strand on the list

L’Artusi calls it Pici ‘Cacio e Pepe’ and lists it at $23, which makes it the cheapest pasta on a menu that climbs to $42 for the artichoke ravioli. Pici is hand-rolled and irregular, closer to a fat udon than to spaghetti, and it gives the dish real chew. The address is 228 West 10th Street. Reservations release on Resy on a two-week rolling basis each day at 9am, with bar and counter seats held back for walk-ins on a first-come basis. If you are bringing a bottle, corkage is $55.

Best suited to anyone who books ahead, or who is happy to eat at the bar on short notice.

Rubirosa, for the straightforward Roman reading

Rubirosa lists Roman Cacio e Pepe with black pepper, spaghetti and pecorino under its handmade pasta heading. Spaghetti is the least fashionable choice on this page and the most familiar, which is exactly the point. The kitchen also notes that its homemade pastas contain eggs except for the lumache and cavatelli, useful if you are ordering around an allergy. It sits at 235 Mulberry Street in Nolita and runs 11am to 10pm Sunday through Thursday, to 11pm Friday and Saturday.

Best suited to a table that cannot agree, since the same menu carries pizza.

Novitá, for the quiet weekday version in Gramercy

Novitá lists Tonnarelli freschi al cacio e pepe at $27, described on the menu as traditional Roman fresh spaghetti with pecorino and coarse black pepper. The strand is both the correct Roman shape and made fresh, which is rarer on New York menus than the wording usually suggests. This is a traditional dining room at 102 East 22nd Street, a block off Park Avenue South and considerably calmer than anything a few blocks west in the Flatiron. Novitá does not publish daily hours on its site, so call before you build a lunch around it.

Best suited to a weekday meal where the conversation matters more than the room.

Zero Otto Nove, for bucatini with a Campanian accent

Zero Otto Nove lists a Bucatini Cacio e Pepe, but the menu around it comes from Salerno rather than Rome, with a Rigatoni Salernitana and a Bistecca alla Salernitana sitting beside it. Bucatini is hollow, so sauce ends up inside the strand as well as on it, and it is the most forgiving shape here if you like a heavier bite. Ordering a Roman dish in a Campanian kitchen is less a contradiction than a different set of instincts about salt and fat. The Manhattan address is 15 West 21st Street. Check the restaurant’s current menu and hours before visiting.

Best suited to a table that wants pizza and pasta on the same bill.

Tarallucci e Vino, for the odd-hours option

Tarallucci e Vino near Union Square lists a cacio e pepe on its pasta section and, separately, a chips cacio e pepe, which is the same seasoning applied to something you eat standing up with a drink. The room at 15 East 18th Street covers the hours everyone else leaves empty, and that is the whole argument for it.

Best suited to a 3pm lunch, or the meal you eat because you missed the other one.

One aside worth knowing. Union Square Cafe at 101 East 19th Street lists Corn Fritters Cacio e Pepe at $14 under bar snacks on its dinner menu, with pecorino, black pepper and honey. It is not a pasta. Go expecting one and you will be annoyed. As a way of putting pecorino and pepper on something else entirely, it is worth the walk over from Union Square, and it belongs to the wider argument about Italian small plates and where the format works.

If the shape question has you rethinking where to eat rather than what to order, our neighborhood-by-neighborhood ranking of where Italian actually clusters here puts these rooms in relation to each other, and the six modern kitchens between Union Square and NoMad is the one to read if you want pasta served as a course rather than as a plate.

For the wider table, there is a sound argument about which Italian dishes survive being passed around and a course-by-course walk through an Italian menu. If you would rather judge a kitchen on one benchmark dish instead of this one, the chicken parm test is the other way to do it.

Frequently Asked Question

Why does cacio e pepe go grainy at home but not in a restaurant?

Heat is almost always the culprit. Pecorino seizes and separates when it hits a pan that is too hot, so the cheese clumps into strings instead of melting into a sauce. Restaurant kitchens finish the dish off the direct flame, using starchy pasta water and hard agitation to build an emulsion rather than melting cheese into fat. The other common mistake is water that is too clean. Cook a small amount of pasta in a large pot and there is not enough dissolved starch left to hold anything together. Use less water than feels right, grate the pecorino finer than feels necessary, and take the pan off the burner before the cheese goes in.

Before you go

Menus move, and cacio e pepe comes and goes with the season at kitchens that cook to the market. Everything above came off each restaurant’s own site in early August 2026. Check the current menu before you cross town for one specific bowl.