Best Meatballs in NYC: Appetizer Order or Pasta Plate
Marco Reale · November 6, 2026 · 7 min
Best meatballs in NYC by format: Emmett's $14 appetizer and $26 spaghetti plate, Bar Primi's $26 meatball parm hero and Cafe Fiorello's two-or-four order.
At $14 for the appetizer, $6 for one more meatball and $26 for the spaghetti plate, Emmett’s on Grove, 39 Grove Street, is this guide’s pick for the best meatballs in NYC among six menus read, and the only one that prints all three prices. For ordering by the count the pick is Cafe Fiorello, with short rib meatballs two for $12 or four for $22, and for a meatball parm hero it is Bar Primi, which prints one at $26 on its lunch menu. Prices and menu lines below come from each restaurant’s own website, checked in October 2026; the picks rest on those pages, not on tasting.
Which Italian menus in NYC carry meatballs, and in what format?
Six menus carry meatballs, in five formats: appetizer, spaghetti plate, hero, platter and pasta sauce. Verified October 2026 from each restaurant’s own menu page; confirm before crossing town for one dish.
| Restaurant | Address | Best for | Dishes and prices |
|---|---|---|---|
| Emmett’s on Grove | 39 Grove Street | Appetizer, add-on and plate priced | Meatballs $14, extra meatball $6; Spaghetti & Meatballs $26 |
| Cafe Fiorello | 1900 Broadway | Ordering by the count | Short Rib Meatballs two $12, four $22; Spaghetti & Short Rib Meatballs $30 |
| Bar Primi | 349 W 33rd Street, Penn District | A priced meatball parm hero | Meatballs in sugo $16; Our Meatball Parm Hero $26 on the lunch menu |
| La Pecora Bianca | 54 Prince Street, SoHo | An appetizer, nothing more | Meatballs (beef and pork, pomodoro sauce, parmesan) $19 |
| Parm | 248 Mulberry Street | Four formats, no prices | Meatballs, a meatball parm sandwich, spaghetti & meatballs, a meatball parm platter |
| Don Angie | 103 Greenwich Avenue | Meatballs inside a pasta | Garganelli Giganti with Broken Meatball Ragu $29 |
How were these meatballs ranked?
Three criteria, each answerable from the menu page alone:
- A price on the dish itself, not only on a set menu.
- A commitment on the line: the meat named, a count, or a price for one more.
- More than one format from the same kitchen.
This ranks the six menus read, not the city. Emmett’s meets all three criteria, as does one other menu, Cafe Fiorello’s, and the tie goes to the only one that prints a price for a single extra meatball: an editorial call on one menu line. Bar Primi’s hero line names no meat, but it is the only hero with a price. Emmett’s calls itself a supper club and says it serves “Italian American favorites,” so its place here rests on the menu. Parm prints no price for any meatball dish and fails the first criterion, but it is the only menu to list four formats. La Pecora Bianca and Don Angie each list one format and fail the third.
Which appetizer order of meatballs is the best pick?
Emmett’s on Grove. The Dinner menu names the blend, “pork, veal, spicy sausage blend,” prints $14, and is the only one of the six to price a single extra meatball, at $6; the Brunch tab repeats both figures. The page does not say how many meatballs come in a $14 order. Of the three menus that print one price and no count, $14 is the lowest, ahead of Bar Primi’s meatballs in sugo at $16 and La Pecora Bianca’s at $19.
Cafe Fiorello is the only menu that prices the appetizer by the count. Its All Day Menu sells Short Rib Meatballs two for $12 or four for $22, which is 6 dollars a meatball for two and 5.50 dollars for four (22 divided by 4). The Brunch tab prints four for $20 instead.
La Pecora Bianca is where the format ends: its Lunch and Dinner menu lists Meatballs as “beef and pork, pomodoro sauce, parmesan” at $19, and its pasta list names a burrata add-on for $7 but no meatball option.
Is spaghetti and meatballs worth more than the appetizer?
Two kitchens print both a plate price and an appetizer price, so the gap is exact.
- Emmett’s on Grove: Spaghetti & Meatballs is $26 under Mains on the Dinner tab, 12 dollars above its appetizer. The line has no description, so whether the plate uses the appetizer’s blend is a question for the restaurant.
- Cafe Fiorello: Spaghetti & Short Rib Meatballs is $30, 8 dollars above the four-meatball order, and the name gives the meat.
So the plate costs 8 to 12 dollars more than the appetizer where both are printed, and the question is whether the table wants a main course, not meatballs. Parm describes its plate, “imported pasta served with our sauce & juicy meatballs,” but prints no price for it.
Where is the best meatball parm hero in NYC?
Bar Primi. Its Lunch tab lists “our meatball parm hero,” “mama’s recipe,” at $26 under Sandwiches, above the $24 gabagool and below the $27 chicken cutlet muffuletta. The Prix-Fixe Lunch tab lists the same hero among four secondi on a 3-course menu at $39, Monday to Friday, 11:30am to 3:00pm, which is 13 dollars more than the hero alone and adds a piccolini and a dolci. The hero is not on the Dinner or Brunch tabs, and the hours page lists lunch for the same weekday window, so the pages tie it to weekday lunch.
Parm’s Mulberry Street menu is the alternative when price can wait. It lists MEATBALL PARM among its sandwiches, with the warning that “when meatballs go between bread they tend to pop out the other side,” and a Platters entry of “3 of our tender meatballs served under a blanket of homemade mozzarella & our sauce.” Its $25 lunch special, 11am to 3pm daily, offers chicken and eggplant parm rolls but no meatball one.
Is Don Angie’s meatball ragu the same as a plate of meatballs?
No. Don Angie’s pasta list has one meatball dish, Garganelli Giganti with Broken Meatball Ragu, guanciale and pecorino, at $29. The menu calls it a ragu, so the meat is part of the sauce rather than a separate piece. Lunch at 103 Greenwich Avenue runs Friday to Sunday only, 11:30am to 2pm, and dinner starts at 5pm Monday to Thursday and 4pm Friday to Sunday.
Cafe Fiorello’s lasagna also carries a meatball, listed as “shortrib beef, meatball, burrata,” and is priced in the best lasagna in NYC verdict.
What should a table order, and where?
Hours and booking rules below are as each restaurant’s site listed them in October 2026.
- Emmett’s on Grove: the appetizer, an extra meatball or the plate from one menu. Dinner starts at 5PM Monday to Thursday and brunch at 11AM on weekends; reservations take parties of up to 7, up to 21 days ahead.
- Cafe Fiorello: one meatball per person, ordered by the count. It opens at noon Tuesday to Thursday and at 10am on Saturday and Sunday.
- Bar Primi: a weekday lunch hero. It accepts reservations, opening 4 weeks ahead, and walk-ins.
- Parm: all four of its formats from one menu, open 11am to 10pm daily.
- Don Angie: a sit-down pasta with the meatballs in the sauce.
The cutlet gets the same published-price treatment in the best chicken parm in NYC, and ordering a whole table of small plates is covered in Italian small plates in NYC. A sister site’s guide to judging a spaghetti and meatballs plate covers technique.
Frequently asked questions
Where can you get the best meatballs in NYC?
On published menus, the best meatballs in NYC are at Emmett’s on Grove, 39 Grove Street, where Emmett’s Meatballs are $14 and Spaghetti & Meatballs is $26 as of October 2026. Cafe Fiorello sells short rib meatballs two for $12 or four for $22, and Bar Primi’s lunch menu has the only priced meatball parm hero here, at $26. These are editorial picks.
How much do meatballs cost at an Italian restaurant in NYC?
As of October 2026, an appetizer of meatballs is $14 at Emmett’s on Grove, $16 at Bar Primi and $19 at La Pecora Bianca, while Cafe Fiorello sells two for $12. A spaghetti and meatballs plate is $26 at Emmett’s on Grove and $30 at Cafe Fiorello, and Bar Primi’s meatball parm hero is $26.
Do NYC Italian restaurants serve spaghetti and meatballs?
Some do. Emmett’s on Grove lists Spaghetti & Meatballs at $26, Cafe Fiorello lists Spaghetti & Short Rib Meatballs at $30, and Parm lists spaghetti & meatballs without a price. La Pecora Bianca lists meatballs only as an appetizer, and Bar Primi lists them as an appetizer and a hero but not with spaghetti, on the menus read in October 2026.
What is the difference between meatballs in sugo and a meatball parm?
Sugo is the Italian word for sauce, so meatballs in sugo are meatballs served in sauce; Bar Primi lists them as a $16 appetizer with no further description. A meatball parm adds melted mozzarella: Parm’s platter is “3 of our tender meatballs served under a blanket of homemade mozzarella & our sauce,” and Bar Primi’s hero is $26 at lunch.


